Gonna Try For That Boy?

Yesterday was National Sister’s Day—a holiday like so many others these days that I had no idea existed—but one that brought a smile to my face. I’m happy because as a mother of not one, but two little girls, I get to celebrate an amazing bond of sisterhood shared between my daughters.

same-gender-families

[ReviewDisclaimer]

Sisterhood is just one thing I love about being a #girlmom, but the list certainly doesn’t end there. So it still surprises me a little when I get THE QUESTION. 

Maybe you’ve gotten it, too.

“When are you gonna try for that boy?”

….

At some point it’s come from family. Other times, friends. Both, only a smidge serious in their inquiry.

same-gender-families

But most often than not, the interrogation into my family’s personal choice to reproduce comes from complete strangers. We’re at the park, the grocery store, TARGET! My girls are riding in the shopping cart together and like a sixth sense, I can almost feel THE QUESTION coming. The obnoxious matching Pepto Bismol [amazon_textlink asin=’B0789GSZYZ’ text=’pink dresses‘ template=’ProductLink’ store=’poms2moms-20′ marketplace=’US’ link_id=’798f0b74-996e-11e8-a5dc-ef9e1f1e247e’] (of their own choosing) probably made us an easy target.

I hear it so often… is it weird that I still don’t know how to respond?

THE QUESTION is innocent enough in nature, I know. As a society, I suppose there’s this unspoken expectation that inserts 1 boy/1 girl offspring into our subconscious illustration of the perfect family. Or maybe 3 females out and about is a lot to take in… we CAN look like a bit of a circus.  Or maybe, even living in 2018, we’re still at a place where boys are deemed essential to carrying on the family legacy. (THE QUESTION has also been rephrased as “When are you giving your husband a son?” The feminist in me throws up in my mouth a little.)

same-gender-families

So here I stand at a crossroads of taking offense or offering pleasantries, wondering if I should just give my best southern “bless your heart” smile OR if I should go into the details of my husband’s vasectomy.

Because we’re not trying for that boy.

same-gender-families

I’m not a total fragile snowflake here … I understand they mean well. I mean hello—if you’ve been a parent of a particular gender, (or both,) you possess a lifetime of memories and experiences of raising a child of that gender. If you have a little boy, I know you can’t possibly imagine life without one. Children have a way of changing you, like that.

I also have a goofy little brother whom I love with my whole heart. My husband is one of two boys. It’s not lost on me that our family expected, or may have even wanted a boy when we announced we were pregnant with our second. (I mean heck, I’ll admit I thought I was having a boy!) I get it – little dudes are cool.

So I’ll smile at them, and acknowledge how much fun boys can be—I’ll be aware of it as common knowledge, but I’ll never really know. I don’t have a son. And while I’ve happily come to terms with it, I briefly flash back to the 5 minutes in the doctor’s office when I was still processing it.

same-gender-families

There was an instant when I realized no new adorable [amazon_textlink asin=’B072Q2VS57′ text=’tiny grandpa clothes‘ template=’ProductLink’ store=’poms2moms-20′ marketplace=’US’ link_id=’b9af36ef-996e-11e8-9be6-dbb39f2ed099′] were getting hung in my baby’s nursery… and I had to cross off the “boy sports” my son would have played. I also thought about how later on I won’t get to talk to him about girls when he starts dating, and when he finds “the one,” I’ll never have a mother-son dance.

[amazon_link asins=’B073YJQZ12,B075RNXWNY,B0764R3GJL,B07BK2HWG9,B07C3QD9QX,B07F7JRGFL,B072C3XSHK’ template=’ProductCarousel’ store=’poms2moms-20′ marketplace=’US’ link_id=’8c2d6885-9966-11e8-a31f-33e83dda651b’]

Boy moms, you get a similar question. And I see you. And somehow, we see ourselves in one another.

Because for every time I hear about that special mother/son bond, or what it’s like to raise larger than life, rambunctious boys… I know what YOU’RE hearing. You’ve told me.

No princesses and fairy tale tea parties. No girly trips to the nail salon. You won’t have the blessing of watching your own child become a mother, and share in the maternal experience that made you feel the way you do for your son.

[amazon_link asins=’B076K5L2K4,B075RNB6YY,B06XJRB1PK,B077JC1FRV,B071KWNWQ5,B078KK9CN1′ template=’ProductCarousel’ store=’poms2moms-20′ marketplace=’US’ link_id=’a634c508-9966-11e8-bed2-b5a273187ad1′]

These thoughts fly past me, but it’s back to THE QUESTION. As much as they don’t realize I’ve already processed the things I’ll miss by not having a boy, the thing is… I don’t care about that. I don’t even really care about me, here.

The purpose of this post is I don’t want my daughters hearing it.

same-gender-families

At ages 3 and 1, they might not understand the full context of adult conversations, but I don’t love outsiders looking in at my sweet girls and insinuating that they’re not enough; that somehow, our family is incomplete without an extra set of XY chromosones.

So here we are… back at Target, still not knowing what to say. Instead, I reflect on the joy in my life because of these two little girls, not all of the things a stranger thinks I’m lacking.

My daughters are so much more than a jigsaw puzzle with a missing piece.

As a final thought, one of my girlfriends, already a mother to an amazing little girl, shared with me that she recorded her gender reveal for baby number two. As the announcement is made and a sweet little pastel pink cupcake is cut open, you can hear a family member comment, “Aw noooo.”

A bit hard to swallow… isn’t it?

So if this sounds like a rant, I instead want it to serve as a small reminder. Instead of focusing on what we DON’T have, please recognize what we DO HAVE.

We have healthy babies. LOVED babies. And isn’t this what’s important?

same-gender-families

same-gender-families

Do you have a brood of all boys? A group of all girls? I’d love to hear from you!

About The Author

Kaitlin

Founder & author of the parenting & lifestyle blog, Poms2Moms. Wife, girl mom, and lover of all things outdoors, food, and wine. Travel is my love language, Netflix binges… my guilty pleasure. Find me writing about toddler drama, baby’s first year, progressive parenting, and more. Cheers! – Kaitlin

26 COMMENTS

  1. Liz Chapman | 6th Aug 18

    Yes people have a tendency to ask or say the most absurd things. After my daughter was born we were asked when were we going to try for that boy. When I got pregnant the second time my MIL noted she hoped it would be a boy to carry on the family name and when we found out it was indeed a boy one “friend” sent her condolences. Seriously, how do you even respond??

    • Kaitlin | 7th Aug 18

      Liz, you can’t win! I guess maybe at some point in life you lose your filter, but when you think about how many women suffer from PPD, miscarriage, infant loss, etc – it’s not hard to stop and think before you open your mouth about children.

  2. Diane | 6th Aug 18

    People have such a tendency to insert their opinions into your life as soon as you have kids! I have 7 so you can imagine the comments!

    • Kaitlin | 7th Aug 18

      “7!!! You must have your hands full!!!” (Just kidding, obviously.) It’s crazy because they insert opinions BEFORE you have kids, too. I wasn’t sure I wanted children at all but for the first 3.5 years of my marriage, that was THE topic of conversation. It’s just strange because that would be the farthest thing from my mind, especially in conversation with a perfect stranger.

  3. Mary | 7th Aug 18

    Crazy how insensitive people can be! When I read the beginning of this post all I kept thinking was I hope my next baby is a girl so my daughter has a sister. Some people always want to bring negativity to a beautiful thing. Thank you for the well written post.

    • Kaitlin | 7th Aug 18

      Thank YOU, Mary! I admit early on in my pregnancy, I sort of always thought baby #2 was a boy so I “get” where people are coming from. But having my second daughter was such an eye-opening experience and seeing them as sisters, (something I personally never got to experience,) is so precious! Thank you for reading. 🙂

  4. Jen Germani | 7th Aug 18

    I hear you! As a mom of 2 sweet little boys, I hear it all the time. And with sky being only five months old we are not even contemplating the possibility of a number three yet, but we are not done yet, necessarily and it has nothing to do with gender and more the fact of loving babies in my life. You are right though, it is incredible to me who feels the need to comment

    • Kaitlin | 7th Aug 18

      No one is safe! Whether you have all girls, all boys, one child, no children, 5 children – people always ask about more. It’s like they’re really worried about keeping the Earth populated. 😉 Thanks for reading Jen, and keeping me updated with your posts of your sweet little guys. I love them!

  5. Selenah | 7th Aug 18

    I have 3 boys and am currently 9 weeks along. I can admit I want a girl lol
    But as my 10 yr old/youngest loves to say “you get what you get and don’t throw a fit!”
    People are so insensitive. I have 2 by one man and 1 by another and I will have actual adults asking me if they’re all by the same man. It’s amazing the boldness. And now that I am blissfully expecting, the theme is “oh but youre starting all over!”
    Yes. Yes I know.

    • Kaitlin | 7th Aug 18

      Selenah – Congratulations!! That’s so exciting. I love big families, (I just can’t be the mom of them…) 😉 The gall of some people though – I don’t know how I would have responded. And good for you “starting over.” You’ll get to experience babyhood with a fresh set of eyes and a tenured perspective on how quickly it all goes. Good luck, mama!

  6. Kayla | 9th Aug 18

    I’m not sure why people think they need to comment on a woman’s desire or lack of desire to get pregnant. Like seriously it has nothing to do with them. We have four and I always get comments.

    • Kaitlin | 13th Aug 18

      Kayla, exactly! One kid, 2 kids, it doesn’t matter. I know people don’t mean any ill will, and if you want to talk to me (positively) about the babies I already have – I could go on for days! But it’s almost NEVER about how lucky I am to have two girls, and it’s a little heartbreaking.

  7. Jason Hoover | 10th Aug 18

    This is so good and so important. You are right they do not deserve to hear it. I am a SAHD with two boys so I am on the complete flipside of the coin. (Vasectomy as well) I respond, ” We’ve been trying for years, but thanks for bringing it up and walk away.” I am not sure what I will do when the boys start understanding. Some of the worst ?’s one can ask anyone are about birthing children. My wife had postpartum cardiomyopathy after our first and it was always devastating when people asked, “When’s the next one coming?”

    • Kaitlin | 13th Aug 18

      Jason, thank you for the read! I’m glad you’re direct in your response. On a bad day, I’ve looked right back at them and said, “Shoot, you’re right! How do I return this one?” 😉 But you’re absolutely right, on the worst end of the spectrum, you have no idea if someone can’t get pregnant, had a miscarriage, or LOST a child. The conversation is barely suited for friends and family, much less a total stranger.

  8. Cilna Schultz | 10th Aug 18

    Mom of 2 beautiful girls. 4j8m and 33days…

    Must admit that I myself was a bit disappointed when we heard it wasnt a boy… but I wouldnt change it for anything now.

    My family is full of pigeon pairs, both mom and dad’s side. Hubby’s family is mostly men. Our 1st born was the 1st female in 18yrs on his side.

    We dont want anymore children and we are very happy with our 2 princeses.

    People will always have an opinion, no matter what happens… they just cant be pleased.

    • Kaitlin | 13th Aug 18

      Cilna – “pigeon pairs.” I’ve never heard of that! I was in your same boat; I was disappointed for all of 5 minutes when I found out what I was missing, only because I hadn’t considered everything I gained in having sisters. They’re seriously sunshine, and I couldn’t imagine our family without BOTH of them. People will always have opinions – you’re right – but you know what they say about opinions… 😉

  9. Rachel | 13th Aug 18

    I have one little girl and recently mentioned to my mom that we are only planning to have one more child. Her response was “I wish I could promise you it will be a boy, but not everyone gets that lucky”. I seriously gagged. My husband and I would be thrilled either way. There’s even a small part of me that would love for my daughter to have a little sister.

    • Kaitlin | 13th Aug 18

      Ugh, good for you, Rachel! I heard the same thing when I had my first. But like others here have said, you’ll hear it no matter what. One kid, 5 kids, no kids, EVERYONE has an opinion. I’m happy to hear YOU know what’s best for your family. <3

  10. Dawn | 13th Aug 18

    I have 1 boy and I’m wanting baby #2. My sister-in-law has 2 boys and I remember the moment I first saw them wrestling and thought, “please Jesus don’t let me have boys”. I now have boy 1 and love him like crazy. While I know I hope for a girl next time around, I also know I will love the next baby, boy or girl. That being said, I’m grateful for your thoughts and so appreciate your heart. My whole family has only 1 gender and I already struggle with answering those dumb questions people ask so your thoughts really help no matter which way baby #2 takes (if we are so lucky to have #2)

    • Kaitlin | 13th Aug 18

      Dawn, isn’t it funny how your perspective changes? And I’m sure your little guy would be the best big bro to a little brother OR sister, so if YOUR family is happy… what else matters? Thank you for the kind words. I wish you the best when/if #2 comes around. You sound like a great mama. <3

  11. Ely | 13th Aug 18

    I have 3 daughters.
    And I will admit that I wanted that son, I love my husband am much he’s my high school sweetheart and he’s just amazing. If I told you just how much, you’d fall in love too so naturally I wanted a mini him and everyone knew that.
    So here comes pregnancy #3 and when we found out it was a girl I will completely honest
    Here and admit that there is such a thing as gender disapointment and that is Intensified with the pregnancy hormones and with the fact that everyone knew you wanted to have that little boy and it’s just not going to happen and they love to remind you of it
    I honestly felt like I had lost something I never had and I had a hard time with it so I’m
    Glad I came across this. I loved it

    • Kaitlin | 13th Aug 18

      Ely, thank you for being so honest. <3 I can sympathize with the feeling. I read something once that said that even as kids, we imagine our futures and all of the endless possibilities they hold. So when a door shuts, (like a "boy" no longer being an option,) you also mourn the end of the boundless future you imagined. I'm sure it's hard, and what's probably worse is the guilt you have for having those feelings. But you have those little ladies for a reason, and I'm sure they're very lucky to have you for their mama.

  12. Christie | 15th Aug 18

    I have two boys. my mother in law actually bought girl clothes as soon as we announced we were expecting our second. No pressure! After two miscarriages we know we aren’t trying for a third. Sometimes I’m sad that I’ll never have that mother/daughter bond but my losses make me realize what a miracle it is to have two healthy children. Boys or girls, they are a gift! I don’t want to lose a minute!

    • Kaitlin | 16th Aug 18

      Christie – so sorry to hear about your babies. <3 I know that puts a lot into perspective, and a WHOLE OTHER REASON why I wrote this. Miscarriage and infant loss are much harsher realities than simply deciding not to have another child to check off a box for gender, so I hope it informs people to be a little more cautious in their comments. Thank you for reading and sharing your story!

  13. Jessica | 18th Aug 18

    I loved the honesty in your article. We just welcomed our third beautiful boy on July 5th. And while pregnant with him, I was hoping for a little girl, I knew that as soon as they placed that precious baby in my arms, gender wouldn’t matter. So when we found out baby #3 was a boy, I silently cried in privacy but then thought how great 3 of one gender will be! And on the night of July 5th, when the labor nurses placed our third son in my arms, I just fell in love! We are planning a 4th but like my OB told me, we know it’s going to be boy and it’s going to be fantastic. Thank you for writing this. Like you and many of your readers, we are already getting “comments” about all our boys, especially if we go out somewhere. I always tell them that this is life I was meant to have and we love it.

    • Kaitlin | 18th Aug 18

      Jessica, thank you SO MUCH for sharing. I am positive you’re an incredible mom – not just a #boymom – and those little guys are lucky to have you. I firmly believe we have the children we are supposed to have, and there’s going to be an unbreakable bond among your boys, whether #4 ends up being another brother, or hey – maybe a sister! Good luck to you either way, and don’t let the comments get to you. <3 Thank you for reading.

Leave A Comment